Diplomats call for closure of base at Guantanamo

March 6, 2006 - 0:0
WASHINGTON (Telegraph) -- The Government's official line on the Guantanamo Bay detention camp was mired in confusion yesterday as ministers and diplomats contradicted each other on whether it should close.

Disagreements inside the Cabinet emerged last week when Peter Hain, the Northern Ireland Secretary, said the base should close although Tony Blair would only say it was "an anomaly".

Yesterday, John Reid, the Defense Secretary, signaled that it was not up to Britain to tell the U.S. how to respond to terrorist attacks on its soil.

"The Americans lost several thousand people. I'm not going to tell the Americans how to deal with the response to international terrorism," Mr. Reid told BBC1's Sunday AM program.

But the British, French and German ambassadors to Washington added their voices to the growing condemnation of the camp after a UN human rights report called for it to close.

Sir David Manning, the British ambassador, said yesterday in a joint appearance by the three envoys on CNN: "We understand the context - you've lost a lot of people.

"It is difficult to find the right line to draw but it is clearly an anomaly and it needs to be dealt with."

The French ambassador, Jean-David Levitte, went further in his condemnation, saying: "Guantanamo is an embarrassment, and so it has to be solved one way or the other. It's necessary to have the people in Guantanamo get a fair trial."

Mr. Reid's comments came ahead of a speech today in which he will plead for understanding of the challenges now faced by British troops by saying that Al-Qa'eda poses an even greater evil than the Nazis in the Second World War.

The plea, along with a warning that British troops feel constrained by human rights laws, follows the discovery last week of a video showing British troops in southern Iraq beating unarmed demonstrators.

But Mr. Hain responded by insisting that the Cabinet was united on Guantanamo even as he repeated that the base should be shut down. The Government's position was that "we don't believe that Guantanamo should have been there. We wished it weren't. The consequences of that is we think that it should be closed down."

The Conservatives, who indicated last week that America's perceived treatment of detainees was backfiring, seized on the confusion. George Osborne, the shadow chancellor who last week was part of a Tory delegation to Washington DC, called for the detention base to be shut down. Mr .Osborne told BBC1's Politics Show that his personal view was that "it should be closed sooner rather than later."

He added: "I think there are few people in the world who would not say that Guantanamo Bay has undermined the moral authority of what we're trying to do."

In his speech today at King's College, London, Mr. Reid will urge people to be "slow to condemn" British forces serving in difficult conditions abroad.

The Defense Secretary will plead for understanding by saying British soldiers today face an unprecedented enemy. The "unconstrained terrorist" was "an enemy unrecognizable from the past" and an adversary who was "unfettered by any sense of morality".

Never before had Britain faced such an enemy, claimed Mr. Reid, who yesterday indicated that Britain had to commit about 3,000 troops to Afghanistan as the greater danger was not to send in more forces.