Middle East peace ‘only if Israel is held accountable’
October 6, 2009 - 0:0
Peace in the Middle East would be achieved only once the U.S. and the European Union (EU) had held Israel accountable for its violations of international law, human rights veteran John Dugard said on Saturday.
Dugard was the United Nations’ (UN’s) special rapporteur on “violations of international humanitarian law and human rights in the occupied Palestinian territories” from 2000 to last year. He is also an acclaimed international law expert and a member of the International Law Commission.After a two-day seminar in his honor at the University of the Witwatersrand on Friday and Saturday , Dugard said Israel was “demonstrably in violation of so many norms of international law”, but that the U.S. was “finding excuses for failing to accept” this and the EU was “no better”.
Israel has consistently denied war crimes and crimes against humanity in Operation Cast Lead, its invasion of Gaza last year. But Dugard said his findings this year on Operation Cast Lead were largely confirmed in a special report to the UN two weeks ago by former Constitutional Court judge Richard Goldstone. His report confirmed “that Israel did commit war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity”, said Dugard.
Both Goldstone and Dugard’s report for the Arab League recommended that war crimes on both sides needed to be investigated.
A vote on Goldstone’s report by the UN’s Human Rights Council has been delayed.
Vera Gowlland-Debbas, professor of international law at the University of Geneva, described how Dugard’s work as special rapporteur was extensively relied on by the International Court of Justice in its “special advisory opinion” on the legality of Israel’s security wall. She said the court’s advisory opinions stated what the existing law was.
It was therefore a matter of decided law that, despite arguments of defense against terrorism, human rights law did “not cease to exist in times of conflict” and that the wall was illegal, she said.
South African international lawyer Max du Plessis said it was brave to “speak truth to power in relation to Israel. That much is more than apparent when one considers the bile that has been directed to Goldstone following his report.
“The rhetoric is vicious, and Goldstone being called a self-hating Jew is but one of the many slurs thrown his way. And Google John Dugard’s name — your breath will be taken away by the vitriol directed at him for his work in respect of Palestine,” said Du Plessis.
Du Plessis and the University of SA’s Prof Marinus Wiechers also described some of Dugard’s international law work in SA.
Dugard was intimately involved in the dispute in the 1960s and 70s over the international law status of Namibia, then South West Africa.
Du Plessis said Dugard’s work was relied on by the Constitutional Court in the Kaunda decision, which recognized that SA had a duty to protect its citizens who faced the death penalty abroad.
This was a shift from the previous view that states had an “absolute discretion” as to whether they should afford diplomatic protection to their citizens who got entangled with the law abroad.
More recently, Dugard and Du Plessis submitted a dossier, on behalf of two nongovernmental organizations, to the National Prosecuting Authority asking it to investigate individuals, including South Africans, who are thought to be guilty of war crimes in Operation Cast Lead.
Dugard said he remained optimistic for a peaceful solution in the Middle East.
(Source: businessday.co.za)