Opaque ECB Report Keeps Markets in Dark on Rates
All that seemed certain on Friday was that the ECB was likely to keep its interest rates unchanged for the time being.
Some analysts said the report, released late on Thursday, signaled a subtle shift in the ECB's thinking toward favoring a near-term cut.
Others said it had merely reiterated that it was inclined to keep interest rates unchanged. One ECB watcher even detected a hawkish stance.
A spokesman for the ECB declined to shed light on which interpretations were the most appropriate.
"We have to let people interpret the statements in the monthly bulletin as they are," he said.
Normally, financial markets get a steer from ECB President Wim Duisenberg through monthly press conferences, but the bank cancelled January's briefing for scheduling reasons.
The ECB predicted in the report that euro zone inflation will decline during 2001 but reiterated that growth was robust and that it still saw a number of risks to price stability.
Differing Conclusions
Morning after interpretations of report varied widely.
Germany's respected Boersen Zeitung newspaper said its "unmistakable" message was: "The (ECB's) desire to cut interest is for now zero, because inflation risks persist and pessimism about the economy is not appropriate."
An editorial in the Financial Times announced "ECB prepares to cut," although in a news article the FT said the ECB report "suggested policymakers were in no hurry to cut rates."
The Wall Street Journal Europe said the bulletin would likely stoke speculation of an interest rate cut, while one news agency said the ECB had maintained its earlier "hawkish tone."
Cut Forecast Brought Forward
Julian von Landesberger, an economist at Hypovereinsbank in Munich, said the January bulletin argued in favor of bringing forward a forecast cut in ECB rates.
"The report seems to point to a little more loosening of monetary policy, a more moderate policy," he said.
"We (now) think the step down in interest rates will take place a little earlier," he said, adding that he now expected a quarter-point cut early in the second quarter rather than at the end of the second quarter.
Jacques Delpla, an economist at Barclays Capital in Paris, said the ECB was neutral now because it was getting conflicting signs from data, but that an easing bias would take hold at the bank soon.
"We are looking for a quarter-point interest rate cut between March 15 and mid-may, depending on developments in the U.S." he said.
"Inflation in the euro zone is falling off a cliff," he added.
Bulletin Signals Neutral Stance
Catherine Lee, an economist at Natwest markets in London, said the bulletin showed a gradual move away from concerns that kept the bank in a tightening mood just two to three months ago.
"Reading between the lines, I got the clear impression that they are less concerned -- that inflation risks are becoming more balanced after being on the upside before," she said.
"The January bulletin may be a very small step toward pointing to an easing bias but I don't think there's an easing bias yet. It's all very neutral," she said.
Ken Wattret, an economist at Paribas in London said the bulletin signaled that the front end of the euro zone bond market has got ahead of itself in expecting a rate cut soon.
"There is no sign in the monthly bulletin that the ECB is about to panic and cut rates imminently," he said.
"But it's pretty obvious that rates will have to fall in the euro zone over the next three to six months. The question is how soon the ECB will feel compelled to deliver."
"It will take a bit of time for the data to convince them," he added.
Natwest's Lee agreed: "Rates are going nowhere in the very near term. The signposts that the market should look at are where the business and consumer confidence surveys go from here," she said.
(Reuter)