First Verdict From Sept. 11 Attacks Due Wednesday

February 18, 2003 - 0:0
HAMBURG, Germany -- A German court will hand down a landmark verdict Wednesday in the first trial worldwide of an alleged conspirator in the September 11 attacks.

The ruling by the five-judge panel on 28-year-old Moroccan Mounir el Motassadeq will be closely watched by international investigators and relatives of the victims in the 2001 attacks in New York, Washington and rural Pennsylvania.

Federal prosecutors believe Motassadeq was a "substantial cog" in the so-called Islamic extremist cell in this northern port city that produced three of the suicide hijackers including alleged ringleader Mohammed Atta.

They have argued during the four-month trial that the electrical engineering student provided key behind-the-scenes logistical help to his friends while they were pursuing flight training in the United States.

The married father of two is charged with "membership of a terrorist organization" and being an accessory to the murder of more than 3,000 people. The presiding judge, Albrecht Mentz, has also said that the court will consider a third, lesser charge of supporting a terrorist organization.

The prosecution has demanded the maximum sentence of 15 years in prison.

Motassadeq avowed his innocence once again in final words to the court last week at the end of the four-month trial, which included wrenching testimony last month from Americans who lost relatives in the attacks.

The prosecution has argued that Motassadeq was a "founding member" of the Hamburg cell who shared the hijackers' hatred of Americans and Jews and was aware of the plan to turn passenger planes into missiles against U.S. targets "at least in its significant outlines" two years before September 11.

They have homed in on a transfer of 5,000 marks (currently worth 2,800 dollars or 2,600 euros) made by Motassadeq in September 2000 from the bank account of Marwan al-Shehhi to that of another suspect, Ramzi Binalshibh.

"The accused did not only understand what was behind this money transfer but he knew that Al-Shehhi was taking flight lessons (in the United States) to prepare a terrorist attack," prosecutor Matthias Krauss said.

Atta is believed to have piloted one of the two planes into the World Trade Center in New York and Al-Shehhi to have flown the other. Binalshibh was arrested in Pakistan a year after the attacks and is now in U.S. custody.

Prosecutors have also emphasized his decision to attend an Al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan in mid-2000, a fact he denied repeatedly during police questioning until he made a surprise admission on the first day of the trial.

His two-man defense team has argued that the prosecution's case is built on guilt by association and anti-Muslim stereotypes and that it has presented no reliable evidence to show that Motassadeq had advance knowledge of the conspiracy.

The defense has also called the trial unfair, calling for a suspension and hinting at an appeal, due to the absence of two witnesses they said could provide exculpatory evidence.

Motassadeq's lawyers had repeatedly demanded that both men, Binalshibh and Mohammed Haydar Zammar, a Syrian-born German and an alleged top Al-Qaeda recruiter who is believed to be in Damascus' custody, be given the chance to tell the court what they know about the inner workings of the Hamburg cell.

But the U.S. government refused to allow Binalshibh to testify and the German government said it would not hand over information it had on Zammar because it was sworn to secrecy by a foreign intelligence service.

The case has resurrected uncomfortable questions for German state security services who have admitted during the trial that they had the Hamburg group in their sights since the late 1990s. (AFP)