The deeper the crisis, the higher the ‘Brown bounce’

November 24, 2008 - 0:0

What is it about Gordon Brown at the moment? “I was standing behind him the other day and even his hair looked confident,” observes Stephen Pound, a Labour MP. In recent weeks the British prime minister has pulled off a remarkable feat of political alchemy: the weaker the economy gets, the stronger he becomes.

The “Brown bounce” has become so pronounced that Labour MPs furtively discuss the idea of exploiting the prime minister’s new-found popularity with a dash to the polls in spring 2009 -- a year earlier than necessary. Such optimism is extraordinary. Britain is entering a bleak recession; government borrowing is spiraling above £100bn ($149bn, €119bn) a year; unemployment is forecast to reach 3m; businesses lack credit. It is a picture of unremitting gloom, but one man is smiling. Mr. Brown’s aides deny he is enjoying the economic crisis. They would. But his decade at the Treasury prepared him for this moment. Anyone spending time with him sees someone galvanized by the challenge of tackling what he calls the “first financial crisis of the global age”.
This is a man unrecognizable from the shrunken, grey figure of the summer of 2008, whose first year in power was marked by policy errors, party infighting and parliamentary by-election humiliations. Labour entered the holiday period 25 points behind the opposition Conservatives.
Mr. Brown retreated to the British seaside town of Southwold for his first proper holiday since taking power. His team say the drizzly North Sea coast did him good. Some attribute his improved mood to a new-found interest in Pilates. But he only really recovered in September when the crisis turned ugly. Within weeks Mr. Brown had cleared the path for a merger of Lloyds TSB and HBOS, nationalized the struggling lender Bradford & Bingley and ordered a ground-breaking £37bn bank recapitalization. “That was when we thought: hang on, something is going on here,” said one Brown aide. “For the first time in a long time we felt in control of events. We seemed to be ahead of the game, rather than talking about lagging lofts.”
As the British economy has tumbled, Mr. Brown has relaxed. As the dole queues have lengthened, the prime minister has grown more secure in his job. Speaking to a business dinner, a mobile phone rang: “That will be another bank going under,” the prime minister beamed.
The plaudits have rained in. Mr. Brown was potentially “the savior” of global capitalism, according to Paul Krugman, this year’s Nobel economics prize winner. Nicolas Sarkozy, French president, made him an honorary member of the eurozone for the day at a summit in Paris to seek his economic wisdom.
All this is as infuriating as it is bewildering for the Tories, whose poll lead has collapsed to as little as three points in recent weeks. All attempts to lay gloves on Mr. Brown have proved futile. George Osborne, the shadow chancellor, admits the turmoil has helped Mr. Brown. “There’s no doubt the current phase of the crisis provides a platform for heads of government,” he says, through gritted teeth. “All these summits, central banks cutting interest rates. Gordon Brown has been on the top of the news almost every night.”
But Mr. Brown’s confidence goes beyond the personal; it is underpinned by a shift of the political balance in favor of centre-left ideas. When Mr. Brown nationalizes a bank, his MPs cheer. The Labour party, emasculated by Tony Blair’s march to the centre, is finding its bearings again. Mr. Brown is also on comfortable Labour ground when he bashes City executives over bonuses -- even if the former chancellor of the exchequer presided over a regulatory regime that made them possible in the first place.
The financial crisis has left the Conservative party squirming. This is the party of Margaret Thatcher, committed to rolling back the state. No wonder Mr. Osborne decried bank nationalization before finally, and reluctantly, endorsing it. When David Cameron, the Conservative leader, denounces excessive City bonuses, he may well mean it. But Labour MPs will always jeer at the stony-faced pin-striped Tory MPs alongside him, some of whom are beneficiaries of those very remuneration schemes.
After months without a compass, the party has alighted on traditional Tory territory: they will fight the next election committed to curbing public spending. It may not be immediately popular -- as Mr. Cameron admits -- but at least the ground is not shifting under their feet. The Tories believe the “Brown bounce” will end in the second phase of the crisis, when people become angry as they lose their jobs and homes. “People will ask who has been responsible for the last 10 years,” says Mr. Osborne.
If he is wrong and Labour starts to overtake the Tories in the polls, Mr. Brown will come under intense pressure to go to the polls early, before the recession gets worse.
John Major, the former Tory prime minister, won the 1992 election in the middle of Britain’s last recession: crucially he was trusted more than Labour to run the economy. Recent polls suggest the British public are again prepared to trust Mr. Brown more than Mr. Cameron to dig the country out of its problems.
“We’re having the election in June next year,” Peter Mandelson, the business secretary, told journalists at a drinks party last week, with a stage wink. In case anyone missed it, he added: “That was a joke.” But around Westminster, the idea is now being discussed with utmost seriousness.
The writer is the FT’s political editor
(Source: The Financial Times)