End budget plan violations
April 19, 2009 - 0:0
The Supreme Audit Court’s report on the implementation of the 1386 national budget plan (March 2007-March 2008) was delivered to the parliament on April 12. It recorded 1463 violations of the law, including 228 cases of illegal payments and violations of trade laws and the terms of the Fourth Development Plan (2005-2010).
However, some lawmakers protested the decision to release the report, arguing that it was “raw” and that the Majlis Planning and Budget Committee was supposed to revise it before it was made public, but this was rejected by the Majlis speaker, who said the committee had no right to change the content of the report.Flouting the national budget laws is unacceptable. Officials may not agree with a particular plan, but they must implement it. Such disregard for the law and lack of accountability only increases and encourages corruption.
This state of affairs has caused Iran’s transparency ranking in economic activities to nosedive from number 83 to number 141 in the world.
Some executive branch officials say that observing the regulations for plans slows down the implementation of public works projects and thus act according to their own whims. But if administration officials think that a plan or law is not applicable or that it can be implemented more efficiently by revising it, they should ask the parliament to amend that particular law.
If officials disregard the law, it sets a bad precedent, leads to a loss of opportunities and a waste of capital, and initiates a cycle of problems. And more importantly, this disregard for the law will make the public lose their trust in state institutions and give rise to rumors of corruption.
For example, during Iranian calendar year 1387 (March 2008-March 2009), the Oil Ministry imported gasoline without asking the Majlis to authorize the money for the purpose, with the oil minister saying that he could not tolerate a situation where there were long queues of cars at gas stations. But Oil Ministry officials definitely could have predicted when the reserves for importing gasoline would dry up.
Many economic experts believe that most of these troubles began with the decision to disband the supervisory Management and Planning Organization, since oversight of economic activities declined afterwards.
Respect for the rule of law is of paramount importance. Government officials should keep this in mind if they want to retain the trust of citizens.