When Will Slogans Translate Into Actions?
September 12, 2000 - 0:0
TEHRAN In his most strong-worded statement yet, Ayatollah Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi, the head of Judiciary, criticized the dogmatic elements who are hindering reforms in the Judiciary and asked them to resign.
"I have said many times that managerial officials in the Judiciary must all feel responsible and make an effort (for reforms in the Judiciary) and whoever is incapable of accompanying me in this path and those who cannot tolerate judicial reforms should step aside and leave the job for others to complete.'' In a meeting on Sunday with the officials of Tehran Justice Department, Shahroudi said the lengthy and time consuming litigation process is itself unjust because some people are deprived of their rights for a while.
Repeating his negative view toward incarceration, Ayatollah Shahroudi added, Imprisonment doesn't have much value in Islamic law but unfortunately the policy of avoiding prison sentences hasn't been adopted by the legislature.'' Shahroudi added, Our objective should be a judicial system that punishes a first degree murderers before the victim is laid to rest. Only then would the revitalizing effects of Islamic retribution law materialize in the society''. We should reach a stage when oppressors and criminals are afraid from the court and when victims invest their trust into the court,'' Shahroudi added.
Elaborating on the duties of the Judiciary, Shahroudi said, The Judiciary has two responsibilities, firstly to bringing about security by reducing felonies, and secondly, establishing justice in the society and defending the oppressed, although bringing about security isn't only our responsibility. With the current situation in the country, we must do all that is in our power to prevent social, moral and religious insecurity.'' The head of the Judiciary continued, Unfortunately, legal and criminal policies haven't been defined on a macro and fundamental level and the role of fines, the philosophy of physical penalties and the limits of incarceration are not clear within the general policies of the system''.
While the latest comments by the head of the Judiciary are a clear sign of his commitment to reforms, analysts doubt whether Shahroudi's views could have any significant effect on the Judiciary as a whole. Ever since Ayatollah Shahroudi took office nearly two years ago, reforms in the Judiciary have more or less been limited to his statements and comments. While criminals have benefited from the light handed approach of the Judiciary head, journalists, intellectuals and political critics have suffered even worst treatment, unprecedented after the Islamic Revolution.
There is no doubt that the Judiciary needs an extensive overhaul, but the Ayatollah Shahroudi hasn't done anything but to admit to the ugly realities that were already evident to our vigilant nation before he accepted office.
There is a huge difference between words and action, and it is hoped that the honorable head of the Judiciary and other officials who have made similar promises start delivering their promises before the nation lose heart in their claims. Meanwhile it was announced on Monday that Ayatollah Shahroudi will visit East Azarbaijan Province this week. Shahroudi's visit to East Azarbaijan will last for two days, during which he plans to examine the legal issues and maladies of the province.
"I have said many times that managerial officials in the Judiciary must all feel responsible and make an effort (for reforms in the Judiciary) and whoever is incapable of accompanying me in this path and those who cannot tolerate judicial reforms should step aside and leave the job for others to complete.'' In a meeting on Sunday with the officials of Tehran Justice Department, Shahroudi said the lengthy and time consuming litigation process is itself unjust because some people are deprived of their rights for a while.
Repeating his negative view toward incarceration, Ayatollah Shahroudi added, Imprisonment doesn't have much value in Islamic law but unfortunately the policy of avoiding prison sentences hasn't been adopted by the legislature.'' Shahroudi added, Our objective should be a judicial system that punishes a first degree murderers before the victim is laid to rest. Only then would the revitalizing effects of Islamic retribution law materialize in the society''. We should reach a stage when oppressors and criminals are afraid from the court and when victims invest their trust into the court,'' Shahroudi added.
Elaborating on the duties of the Judiciary, Shahroudi said, The Judiciary has two responsibilities, firstly to bringing about security by reducing felonies, and secondly, establishing justice in the society and defending the oppressed, although bringing about security isn't only our responsibility. With the current situation in the country, we must do all that is in our power to prevent social, moral and religious insecurity.'' The head of the Judiciary continued, Unfortunately, legal and criminal policies haven't been defined on a macro and fundamental level and the role of fines, the philosophy of physical penalties and the limits of incarceration are not clear within the general policies of the system''.
While the latest comments by the head of the Judiciary are a clear sign of his commitment to reforms, analysts doubt whether Shahroudi's views could have any significant effect on the Judiciary as a whole. Ever since Ayatollah Shahroudi took office nearly two years ago, reforms in the Judiciary have more or less been limited to his statements and comments. While criminals have benefited from the light handed approach of the Judiciary head, journalists, intellectuals and political critics have suffered even worst treatment, unprecedented after the Islamic Revolution.
There is no doubt that the Judiciary needs an extensive overhaul, but the Ayatollah Shahroudi hasn't done anything but to admit to the ugly realities that were already evident to our vigilant nation before he accepted office.
There is a huge difference between words and action, and it is hoped that the honorable head of the Judiciary and other officials who have made similar promises start delivering their promises before the nation lose heart in their claims. Meanwhile it was announced on Monday that Ayatollah Shahroudi will visit East Azarbaijan Province this week. Shahroudi's visit to East Azarbaijan will last for two days, during which he plans to examine the legal issues and maladies of the province.