The Statue-Feller of Bamiyan and Kabul's Realpolitik

May 27, 2001 - 0:0
BAMIYAN, Afghanistan "A sign in the center of the bazaar at Bamiyan leads the visitor to the Buddhas. There is a carpark in front of the larger Buddha statue. Flash attachments and binoculars are recommended." Nancy Hatch-Dupree, a historical guide to Afghanistan, published in 1977. A man like Mullah Abdus Sattar-Haqqani doesn't need a guidebook, or a carpark for that matter. What for? When the Mullah visited the Buddhas for the first time, he simply drove his chunky Toyota Jeep right up to the sheer cliff face. Sattar-Haqqani can do without binoculars and a flash as well. Now that his gunners have destroyed the "wonder of the ancient world" at Bamiyan it is difficult to pick out any details and is certainly not worth photographing. A pile of rubble, a few chunks of stone with the odd straw poking through is all that's left of the two monumental Buddhas, which stood 55 and 38 meters tall and were cut from the sandstone cliff 1,600 years ago. Now two gaping recesses are all that is left of two of "mankind's greated cultural achievements", as the American archaeologist and Afghanistan expert Nancy Hatch-Dupree described the Buddhas of Bamiyan in the 1970s. According to a DPA report, when she was writing, Afghanistan was a peaceful country and the Bamiyan Valley was an international tourist magnet. Binoculars, cameras and flashbulbs were derigueur for tourists travelling to the fertile valley. Bamiyan lies in the middle of the Hindukush, at a height of 2,500 meters, dwarfed by the snow-capped 4,000-meter giants nearby. Nancy Hatch-Dupree's books informed guests of what was worth seeing in this largely unknown land in the heart of Asia. But the high point of any Afghanistan trip was a visit to the giants at Bamiyan -- so huge that they could also be viewed from the air. But that is a long time ago. And who is this Nancy Hatch-Dupree? It would never cross Mullah Sattar-Haqqani's mind to read an English book, and certainly not one written by a woman, no matter how high her standing in the scientific community. And a book that contains images of living beings? When the subject at issue is the destruction of Bamiyan's Buddhas, Mullah Sattar-Haqqani needs no book to refer to; he knows what he knows. "First we shot at the figures with mortars and a tank. When that didn't help, we put dynamite under the Buddhas and blew them up," Mullah said. The barbarity practised by the Mullah and his Taleban government has enraged the world and shocked millions of Buddhists to the core. All in all, it has further isolated the fundamentalist regime in Kabul. Nancy Hatch-Dupree, the archaeologist now in her seventies, sits white-haired and tiny in her office in neighboring Pakistan. "I am very sad. The statues were a work for peace. Proof of the cultural achievements mankind is capable of," she says. "A shot-up house or a bridge -- they can be repaired. But no one will put the Buddhas back together for us." Bamiyan's commander Sattar-Haqqani, as he stands calmly smug in his faith next to the empty recesses where the Buddhas once stood in the cliff wall, is troubled by only one question two months after the statues' destruction: How can he prevent people stealing the Idols's pitiful remains. The mounds of rubble in the recesses are suspiciously small, actually. apparently, the last weeks have seen pieces of Bamiyan's destroyed heritage turn up in Pakistani markets. The pieces are sold for tens of thousands of dollars, sometimes by the Taleban themselves. The Mullah has now posted guards near the empty cliff walls. The majority of the local population, in any case, fled after the fighting around Bamiyan, or were expelled by the Taleban later. The farmers' clay huts now occupied by Taleban soldiers are peppered with bullet holes. But it is evident just how much the debris' disappearance is worrying the Mullah: "I am not like one of these unscrupulous, greedy people." If Hollywood ever came looking for an actor to play a warrior from the Hindukush, the Mullah would be hired on the spot. Nancy Hatch-Dupree in her small, book-filled office in Peshawar could tell the Mullah a few things of course. The name Dupree has after all almost become a household name for international interest and respect for Afghanistan's thousands of years of culture.