Final Tests Confirm Coronavirus Is to Blame for SARS
A test procedure known as Koch's postulates is traditionally used by medical scientists to establish whether a specific virus has caused a disease.
The goal is to cross-check -- to ensure that the disease can be clearly pinpointed to that virus and not to other pathogens that may lurk in samples taken from patients.
The first three criteria -- isolating the virus from diseased hosts; cultivating it in host cells; and proving that the agent passes through a lab filter that traps bacteria, which are bigger than viruses -- have already been met.
Scientists led by Albert Osterhaus of the Erasmus Medical Center in Rotterdam say they have now successfully carried out the three other Koch tests.
These are: Inducing the disease in the same or comparable host; re-isolating the pathogen from the sick animals; and detecting a specific response to the virus from the body's immune system.
The Osterhaus team used macaque monkeys as a close relative to human species to carry out the trio of experiments.
The research could be the final blow to early lab work in the severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) outbreak that suggested another agent was to blame -- a paramyxovirus, which is related to the virus that causes mumps and measles.
Theories also circulated in the early stages of the SARS epidemic that the disease could be caused by a co-infection -- a new pathogen that worked in cahoots with another agent, possibly the chlamydia bacterium.
Osterhaus' team say they can now rule out the idea of a dual infection as the cause of SARS.
But they do not exclude the possibility that chlamydia or a standard pneumonia virus "may have exacerbated the disease" among some patients.
Scientists at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC) put the finger on a new type of coronavirus -- a family of which the cold virus is a member -- in early April.
The genome, or genetic code, of the virus was sequenced on April 12 by the Genome Sciences Center of Canada.
The Osterhaus study is published on Thursday in the British journal Nature. Koch's postulates for viruses are derived from similar guidelines set down in 1890 by the great German microbiologist Robert Koch for identifying diseases caused by bacteria.